Beyond a Shadow of Doubt

Since I posted last, time has flown for me. In deep contrast to the glacial pace of November, the winter months and early spring, time has suddenly accelerated out of control hurtling me forward directly into something I had perceived as being so far away. In five days, I’ll look back seven months and remember my daughter saying, “I love you, too,” for the last time, leaving home for the last time. When she came back through that door it would be as ashes held close to my heavy heart in a small box. Like the head-on collision that took her life, I am now head-on with the task of opening this small box on her birthday in honor of her wishes; to be planted with trees by her loved ones. I still can’t believe she’s gone. I don’t believe she really is. I am beginning to understand the anger I have felt toward those who have told me she is dead. In my heart, she is not dead and she never will be. The sensation is in my heart when I hear someone say it, “she is dead.” It isn’t a sadness, it isn’t a despair, it isn’t grief; it is utter incredulity… “NO – SHE – ISN’T.”

Some may call this a phase of the grieving process but I choose not to believe in those either. I have experienced enough grief in my life to know that it isn’t nearly that tidy. Would that it were. Would that we could simply go down the list, bargaining, denial, anger, guilt, regret, depression, acceptance, check, check, check, done. No, it doesn’t work that way. You’re lying to yourself if you think that it does. I’m trying to do you a favor by suggesting to you that it doesn’t. I also know that when one is grieving the loss of the physical presence of a loved one in their life, the last thing they need is someone doing them any favors.

Who really knows anything for sure? Who can prove anything one way or another? No one. Not me, not anyone. So how do I know my daughter is not dead? I just know. “Prove it,” you may be saying. That’s what people tend to want. Proof.

Recently, on the sixth month anniversary of Dannica’s passing, in fact, I was called to serve on a jury. It was an interesting experience; one I’d not had before. I took my job for the day very seriously. I listened intently, I closely observed everyone involved, I took notes, I wrestled inside with the emotion of viewing everything through the filter with which I’m currently equipped, and I did my best to make a decision based on the evidence as it was presented. Is he innocent? Is he guilty? Where’s the proof? Before we were dismissed to deliberate we were asked to weigh the evidence and make our decision with “moral certitude.” In other words, to ask ourselves, “If I decide this way, will I be able to sleep at night knowing I made the right decision?”

In the end, we decided the burden of proof had not been met. We decided not guilty. And then there was that moral certitude thing. Guess whose mind circled the events of the day like a starving vulture all night long?

It was around this Jury Service time that a friend of mine told me about a television program called Long Island Medium. I looked it up On Demand and watched a few episodes. Finding it quite entertaining, I began to relax into the way the Medium conversed with those who have crossed over. I laughed and I cried along with those whose questions were answered, hearts comforted by messages from the “other side.”

I have my own questions, ones I may never know the answers to. So many questions. I have done my best to piece together the puzzle of my daughter’s death and I have arrived at conclusions that allow me to sleep at night, most nights, or at least most parts of most nights. Ultimately, having my questions answered changes nothing. My baby is not in my arms, not hanging out in her room, not at work, or with her friends… whether I know exactly what happened changes nothing. Or does it? Hearing the Medium’s messages, having some of their questions answered, was enough for some of these people to move forward more peacefully in their lives after being able to release guilt, regret, fear, some of the uncertainty.

Not long after discovering the Long Island Medium, I learned of a book by Annie Kagan; The Afterlife of Billy Fingers: How my bad-boy brother proved to me there’s life after death. I purchased it on my Kindle immediately but I found myself putting off reading it. I was compelled but kept feeling like it wasn’t the right time and I did other things instead. What I didn’t realize until I actually read the book a couple of weeks later was that several things needed to happen in my own life first that would later be validated as messages from my baby girl. Reading the book after these things happened was her way of telling me she knew I was going to read it right when I was and not before. To some this will sound fluffy. So be it. In my heart it makes sense and it excites me and that is why I share it. I understand it may do nothing for you. I understand your skepticism. It doesn’t bother me.

So, I spoke with another very dear friend of mine who happens to be a judge. I told him of my experience as a juror and of my sleepless night of moral un-certitude. He told me, “Anything you are convinced of as the result of expert testimony constitutes proof.” Such a concise definition but one that wasn’t present in my brain when I needed it to be. Thankfully, I now have a new definition and understanding of what constitutes proof for me.

I asked my daughter to send me an elephant so I’d know she was okay. An ELEPHANT! In the moment I knew it was a crazy thing to ask for. How could she send me and elephant? So I asked for a bird. A bird she could probably send me. Then I questioned myself…what if she sent me an elephant and I was looking for a bird? I sat for a moment and then asked for everything… “Send me and elephant AND a bird!?” Not two days passed and what do you think showed up in my email but an inspirational message with photos of, yes, an elephant and a little yellow songbird. I am convinced. To me this constitutes proof. She is with me. She hears me. She can tell me so. And she did.

Again and again I think back to the question posed to me by many in those first dark days, “What has this done to your faith?” I remember saying that my faith was stronger than ever. That seems a contradiction in light of the fact that I’m now more agnostic than ever. None of us can ever really *know* until we are there and at that point, we are not here.

None of this is really proof of anything unless it’s proof to me. That’s all the proof I need. It’s the only proof that matters.

10 thoughts on “Beyond a Shadow of Doubt

  1. Pingback: Yo-Yo-Butt | Hollowed Out…

  2. Sending warm wishes as you continue to move through your loss. I can relate so well to this post. While my personal experience is different, and I am still very much in question about what I believe, and what I have “faith” in, I do believe that what you said is true, the only proof that matters is the proof to ourselves. I am glad you have found this. And thank you for sharing it.

  3. First, I”m so sorry about the loss of your daughter. It sounds like she transitioned around the same time as mine.

    I’m in agreement with all the other comments – I get clear messages from my daughter too, and it is so comforting. I also haven’t written about it much yet on my blog, feeling that it is even more personal than all the other details i am happy to write about. She comes through often in music though, and I know without a doubt when she’s with me.

    I also have received messages from her through 2 mediums, and found that extremely helpful, as well as Eben Alexander’s book Proof of Heaven, which was very reassuring.
    I’m glad you found my blog and led me to yours!

    • Thank you, Lucia, and I am also so very sorry about your loss. Dannica passed away on November 14 of last year; just over 7 months ago. I love hearing about the ways people sense or experience their loved ones who have gone. I read and enjoyed Eben Alexander’s book, as well. Writing here has been therapeutic and I’m in awe of the people I’ve met here. Thank you for reading my blog and I look forward to reading more of yours. ❤

  4. I actually came back to reread this post. I agree with Denise – a bird and an elephant!! WOW!

    After Vic died I bathed her and whilst I was dressing her limp little body I spoke to her and told her I needed a CLEAR sign that she is around me. At her memorial service they could not get the hearse door to close…It only closed on the 3rd attempt! The day I saw the medium her radio/DVD player thing’s door kept opening and closing and the one light in my TV lounge, closest to where I sit, goes off and comes on… Lots of hugs to you. xxx

    • I sat and stared at the screen for the longest time when I saw that image of the elephant and the little yellow songbird. Yesterday my husband and I were sitting in the living room and the gas fire came on by itself. This has happened a number of times. I like to believe it is her. She turned it on more often than anyone else. She was a cuddler and a snuggler. Also, a dear friend of hers came to visit not long ago and when he came through the front door, the little lamp on the entry table turned off and then on again. It is exciting to me though my first instinct is to look for the logical explanation… I’m choosing to overcome that instinct. I want to believe. Hugs to you, too. ❤

  5. My grief counselor worked under Elizabeth Kubler-Ross, who expressed regret at her “five stages.” I don’t think she meant them as The Way. But I think when you’re suffering that badly, you want “The Way.” Philip sends me signs all the time. ALL the time. I often share them because they’re so whacky – he’s a funny kid. I’ve not yet mentioned them on my blog – I’m getting there. In my last post I talk about what Philip said to me when his father told me he was dead. Philip talks to me and he gives me signs. I take dictation from him. And you know what? The more you stay in communication with your child and accept what she’s giving you, the more you’ll hear from her. An elephant and a bird???? Wow.

    Blessings to you in your suffering.

    • The last time I looked over the “five stages,” was about 14 years ago. I had them hanging on a kitchen cabinet with a painting by Thomas Kinkade. I read them every day and I actually did go down the list checking them off. I suppose it is “The Way” for some, it was for me in a different situation. This time, though, nothing is as it’s ever been and none of it fits. You’re right. When you’re suffering so much you want *anything* you can hold onto in hopes of comfort. I’m so encouraged by your interactions with Philip. I will keep talking, listening, and being grateful for every sign. Blessings to you as well. ❤

  6. I actually met with a medium, and there is no doubt in my mind that Vic is okay. I asked for a white feather and periodically receive them. It does not lessen my grief and the dreadful void in my life. I miss my child so much!

  7. So beautiful, and I know she is with you always. I feel my family that has past on are still here. And my Dad is always taling care of me still. So she here don’t doubt it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s